Monday 16 May 2011

Building Green success: Scanning Brighton's political horizon (Part 1)

Over the last few days, those of us living in Brighton and Hove have had our first inkling of what to expect politically over the coming council session. For all of the feverish excitement precipitated by our success at the local elections, the sharp realisation of what controlling our first local authority entails has been a sobering experience for the local party. In the next few days I'm going to write about the new political context in the city and take an educated guess at what challenges the Green Council will face over the next four years.





I'm going to start my analysis today with Labour. No sooner than the results came in at the count than Labour's local leadership moved fast to distance themselves from any talk of coalition with us. Their hasty press release sounded a constructive note and clearly acknowledged our mandate to form the next council, but their positioning neatly left us to shoulder the difficult decisions over the next few years alone. They are generously (!) giving us enough rope to hang ourselves with and leaving themselves space to robustly critique our every move. This is a role that served us well in the past and I don't begrudge their appropriation of it - I personally think it will be important to hold us to account and should assist in tightening our thinking, especially as we get used to our new responsibilities.


On Monday, the Green party membership met collectively to discuss our position and as a result of a sometime robust discussion, we decided to try and re-open negotiations on the budget signed off by the previous administration. In a statement, we asked Labour to work with us to try and reshape spending priorities on the budget in order to take the pressure away from cutting front-line services. Not only does this strategy succeed in drawing Labour closer to our stance of resisting the central government cuts agenda, but I think it sends a strong message that we will aspire to conduct politics more consensually in the city.


Unfortunately, that may be easier said than done. One of the major fault-lines of this particular election has been the souring of relations between Labour and the Greens. I'm sure my perspective differs from theirs, but it has felt to me at times that they seem to resent our appropriation of "their" voters. No party has a right to voter loyalty and our lack of expectation has kept our feet on the ground. This is one of the advantages of coming from nowhere and building up support street by street! Their anger at losing ground in the city is directed squarely at us. At this crucial juncture, it risks preventing us working in a united fashion to blunt the impact of cuts. Already, the tone from Labour activists on Twitter and the influential local politics blog (The Brighton Blogger), is barely keeping within the bounds of civility. Unless cooler heads prevail amongst Labour, this could cause damage to us both. I can foresee real difficulties passing our decisions through full council without some solidarity between our parties. The most vulnerable in the city need us to see beyond our self-interest.


What we must also remember is that in spite of Labour only retaining their current number of council seats, they did increase their share of the vote substantially upon the last set of elections, challenging the Conservatives successfully in some wards. For all of our gains, their share of the actual vote was only 1% behind us, although the spread of votes across wards meant that this didn't translate into actual seats. This signals to me that their poor organisation was more of a contributing factor to our success than we'd like to think, examples of which I observed on the day of the election itself. With a thorough analysis of the hard data and a post-mortem on individual ward performances, we can expect Labour to build substantially upon this support at a future election. Incumbents tend to lose their voters, rather than gain them, as they begin dealing with the compromising realities of wielding power.

Finally, Labour nationally have larger resources and profile than us and it is likely that over the next four years, public attitudes towards the coaltion government will harden, especially now as the public sector job losses are starting to come through and will impact upon our economic growth performance. This could benefit us, but we have to acknowledge that it will provide a compelling case for Labour too.

8 comments:

  1. Thanks for sharing this post.I really like it.Now i eagerly waiting for your next artcile in which you discuss the new political context in the city .

    ReplyDelete
  2. Rest assured, you'll be getting more on that in my next couple of posts! I'll be aiming to look at the new Green Cabinet announced late last week, as well as giving a sense of what the key political issues will be over the course of the next four years in Brighton and Hove. Thanks for reading!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good to get an "insider's" perspective on the fallout from the election. I think both the big two parties have been far too comfortable with the binary political scenario we have in the UK.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Labour would do well to remember that loyalty is not theirs by default or right. It has to be earned. Keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks to you both for your comments! I suspect that Labour locally will have to come to terms with the changes in people's political outlooks here in Brighton. Their real risk is if they see us as an aberration - a protest vote that went to far and will fizzle out as soon as we have to make some tough decisions. It won't play well for them and from the local noises I'm hearing already, what the public are hearing about us is cautiously positive so far.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I just sent this post to a bunch of my friends as I agree with most of what you are saying here and the way you have presented it is awesome!!!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Glad you enjoyed - check out some of my later posts on this, as the situation here in Brighton is evolving on a weekly basis!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Cool post and awesome content. Good luck for your analysis.

    ReplyDelete